diff --git a/src/main/java/edu/harvard/iq/dataverse/DatasetPage.java b/src/main/java/edu/harvard/iq/dataverse/DatasetPage.java
index 20617160a1c..042bcc5a0e7 100644
--- a/src/main/java/edu/harvard/iq/dataverse/DatasetPage.java
+++ b/src/main/java/edu/harvard/iq/dataverse/DatasetPage.java
@@ -387,7 +387,7 @@ public void setSelectedHostDataverse(Dataverse selectedHostDataverse) {
     private boolean showIngestSuccess;
     
     private Boolean archivable = null;
-    private Boolean versionArchivable = null;
+    private HashMap<Long,Boolean> versionArchivable = new HashMap<>();
     private Boolean someVersionArchived = null;
 
     public boolean isShowIngestSuccess() {
@@ -6147,31 +6147,45 @@ public boolean isArchivable() {
         return archivable;
     }
 
-    public boolean isVersionArchivable() {
-        if (versionArchivable == null) {
+    /** Method to decide if a 'Submit' button should be enabled for archiving a dataset version. */
+    public boolean isVersionArchivable(Long id) {
+        Boolean thisVersionArchivable = versionArchivable.get(id);
+        if (thisVersionArchivable == null) {
             // If this dataset isn't in an archivable collection return false
-            versionArchivable = false;
+            thisVersionArchivable = false;
             if (isArchivable()) {
-                boolean checkForArchivalCopy = false;
+                
                 // Otherwise, we need to know if the archiver is single-version-only
                 // If it is, we have to check for an existing archived version to answer the
                 // question
                 String className = settingsWrapper.getValueForKey(SettingsServiceBean.Key.ArchiverClassName, null);
                 if (className != null) {
                     try {
+                        boolean checkForArchivalCopy = false;
                         Class<?> clazz = Class.forName(className);
                         Method m = clazz.getMethod("isSingleVersion", SettingsWrapper.class);
+                        Method m2 = clazz.getMethod("supportsDelete");
+
                         Object[] params = { settingsWrapper };
+                        boolean supportsDelete = (Boolean) m2.invoke(null);
                         checkForArchivalCopy = (Boolean) m.invoke(null, params);
 
                         if (checkForArchivalCopy) {
                             // If we have to check (single version archiving), we can't allow archiving if
                             // one version is already archived (or attempted - any non-null status)
-                            versionArchivable = !isSomeVersionArchived();
+                            thisVersionArchivable = !isSomeVersionArchived();
                         } else {
-                            // If we allow multiple versions or didn't find one that has had archiving run
-                            // on it, we can archive, so return true
-                            versionArchivable = true;
+                            // If we didn't find one that has had archiving run
+                            // on it, or archiving per version is supported and either
+                            // the status is null or the archiver can delete prior runs and status isn't success,
+                            // we can archive, so return true
+                            // Find the specific version by id
+                            DatasetVersion targetVersion = dataset.getVersions().stream()
+                                    .filter(v -> v.getId().equals(id))
+                                    .findFirst()
+                                    .orElse(null);
+                            String status = targetVersion.getArchivalCopyLocationStatus();
+                            thisVersionArchivable = (status == null) || ((!status.equals(DatasetVersion.ARCHIVAL_STATUS_SUCCESS) && (!status.equals(DatasetVersion.ARCHIVAL_STATUS_PENDING)) && supportsDelete));
                         }
                     } catch (ClassNotFoundException | IllegalAccessException | IllegalArgumentException
                             | InvocationTargetException | NoSuchMethodException | SecurityException e) {
@@ -6180,8 +6194,9 @@ public boolean isVersionArchivable() {
                     }
                 }
             }
+            versionArchivable.put(id, thisVersionArchivable);
         }
-        return versionArchivable;
+        return thisVersionArchivable;
     }
 
     public boolean isSomeVersionArchived() {
diff --git a/src/main/webapp/dataset-versions.xhtml b/src/main/webapp/dataset-versions.xhtml
index 9e5f0a9b24d..ee726bb5eee 100644
--- a/src/main/webapp/dataset-versions.xhtml
+++ b/src/main/webapp/dataset-versions.xhtml
@@ -171,11 +171,11 @@
               </ui:fragment>
               <h:outputText  value="#{bundle['file.dataFilesTab.versions.headers.archived.pending']}" rendered="#{'pending' eq versionTab.archivalCopyLocationStatus}" title="#{DatasetPage.isSuperUser() ? versionTab.archivalCopyLocationMessage : ''}"/>
               <h:outputText  value="#{bundle['file.dataFilesTab.versions.headers.archived.failure']}" rendered="#{'failure' eq versionTab.archivalCopyLocationStatus}" title="#{DatasetPage.isSuperUser() ? versionTab.archivalCopyLocationMessage : ''}"/>
-              <p:commandLink rendered="#{DatasetPage.isSuperUser() and DatasetPage.versionArchivable and empty(versionTab.archivalCopyLocation)}" update="#{p:resolveClientId('datasetForm:tabView:versionsTable', view)},:messagePanel" 
+              <p:commandLink rendered="#{DatasetPage.isSuperUser() and DatasetPage.isVersionArchivable(versionTab.id) and empty(versionTab.archivalCopyLocation)}" update="#{p:resolveClientId('datasetForm:tabView:versionsTable', view)},:messagePanel" 
                                                    action="#{DatasetPage.archiveVersion(versionTab.id)}">
                   <h:outputText value="#{bundle['file.dataFilesTab.versions.headers.archived.submit']}"/>
               </p:commandLink>
-              <h:outputText  value="#{bundle['file.dataFilesTab.versions.headers.archived.notarchived']}" rendered="#{ empty(versionTab.archivalCopyLocation) and ((not DatasetPage.isSuperUser() and DatasetPage.someVersionArchived) or (DatasetPage.isSuperUser() and not DatasetPage.versionArchivable))}"/>
+              <h:outputText  value="#{bundle['file.dataFilesTab.versions.headers.archived.notarchived']}" rendered="#{ empty(versionTab.archivalCopyLocation) and ((not DatasetPage.isSuperUser() and DatasetPage.someVersionArchived) or (DatasetPage.isSuperUser() and not DatasetPage.isVersionArchivable(versionTab.id)))}"/>
               
             </ui:fragment>
         </p:column><!-- end: archivalCopy column -->