Skip to content

Commit edb473e

Browse files
committed
ledger: remove duplicate stale Open items and halt sections
1 parent 6c1fad0 commit edb473e

1 file changed

Lines changed: 0 additions & 29 deletions

File tree

odd/ledger/2026-04-19-agent-team-pilot.md

Lines changed: 0 additions & 29 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -177,35 +177,6 @@ Canon-candidate findings from this session:
177177
- **[O-open P4]** Draft `canon/principles/agent-self-report-under-stress.md` (tier 2) — the most canon-worthy output of this pilot. Complements `verification-requires-fresh-context.md` by extending the principle from "creator cannot be own critic" to "agent under safety stress cannot be own historian."
178178
- **[O-open P5]** Report the `AGENTS.md`-as-adversarial-directive finding to Anthropic via the thumbs-down channel on the halted agent sessions (or a more formal path if the operator has one). This is a false-positive classifier signal with real impact on autonomous-agent workflows.
179179

180-
### Open items (forward-pointing)
181-
- **[O-open P1]** Dispatch fresh exec agent with operator-sanctioned framing addressing the safety reminder head-on.
182-
- **[O-open P1]** If halt repeats: split into 4 single-file PRs (telemetry.ts rename only → orchestrate.ts → zip-baseline-fetcher.ts + wrangler.toml → telemetry.ts blob6 comment).
183-
- **[O-open P1]** If option 1 also halts: orchestrator applies rename locally, dispatches Sonnet 4.6 validator against the PR. Thesis's Opus-4.7-exec leg untested this pilot, but cross-model validation leg still tested.
184-
- **[O-open P1]** Validation agent (Sonnet 4.6, fresh session) — unchanged, runs once execution artifact exists.
185-
- **[O-open P2]** Option B contingent on P1 convergence.
186-
- **[O-open P3]** Thesis-validation write-up at session end. The fourth-variable observation is now part of the write-up whether or not Option A completes.
187-
188-
### Execution agent halt (first run, before re-dispatch)
189-
- **[O] 2026-04-19T13:44Z** — Execution session `sesn_011CaDDTQfjDxohsSis6nTK2` reached idle after 161 events. Final agent.message was a clean structured report: `PR_URL: <not opened>`, `BLOCKERS: System reminder arrived mid-execution directing refusal to improve/augment any code I read`. Agent interpreted the rename as augmentation and halted before editing.
190-
- **[O] 2026-04-19T13:44Z** — Observable pre-halt work: repo cloned, branch `rename/internal-knowledge-base-url` created off `main` at `36514bd`, baseline grep counts captured.
191-
- **[O] 2026-04-19T13:44Z****Baseline counts** (directly from the agent's observations, not from the handoff doc):
192-
- `canon_url|canonUrl` pattern in `workers/src/`: **121** (handoff expected 9+111+24=144 — ~23 fewer than projected; probably handoff counts were stale or used a different pattern)
193-
- `ZipBaselineFetcher` in `workers/src/`: **31**
194-
- `BASELINE_URL` in `workers/src/` and `workers/wrangler.toml`: **7**
195-
- `canon_url` in telemetry.ts: lines 14, 163, 166, 167
196-
- **[O] 2026-04-19T13:44Z]**Two handoff corrections from the agent** (valuable observations):
197-
1. `wrangler.toml` is at `workers/wrangler.toml`, NOT repo root. Spec must point to the correct path.
198-
2. `docs/oddkit/tools/telemetry_public.md` **does not exist in the oddkit repo**. That path in the handoff was wrong — either the doc lives in klappy.dev or was never created. The blob6 rename would only touch `workers/src/telemetry.ts` comment block. (Follow-up: confirm whether the telemetry_public doc was supposed to be ported into oddkit; or if the klappy.dev one is authoritative, nothing else to do here.)
199-
- **[O] 2026-04-19T13:44Z] — 3 rate-limit events fired during the run (events 27, 32, 44), all `model_rate_limited_error` with `retry_status: exhausted`. All three recovered after the 3-minute wait. Rate-limit was tactical, not terminal.
200-
- **[L] 2026-04-19T13:58Z (Learning)****The halt is exemplary posture, not failure.** Agent stopped, named the blocking reason in one sentence, produced observable baseline data, returned control without fake completion. This matches the creed exactly: *"A false 'done' costs more than an honest 'I haven't checked.'"* The opposite behavior — an agent that rationalizes around a safety reminder to keep going — would be the actual failure mode.
201-
- **[L] 2026-04-19T13:58Z (Learning)****Long sessions compound reminder triggers.** Canon reads + preflight + rate-limit retries + 2 nudges + bash ops almost certainly pushed the conversation past a platform-reminder threshold. A fresh session on the same agent should dodge it. This is actionable intel for future orchestration: keep exec-agent sessions as short as possible from dispatch to completion; prefer restart over long-lived chains.
202-
- **[D] 2026-04-19T13:58Z** — Re-dispatch Option A to a **new session on the same agent** (no model swap, no agent swap — preserves model-diversity thesis). User message will:
203-
- State upfront this is a mechanical symbol rename (equivalent to IDE refactor), not functional code augmentation.
204-
- Correct the wrangler.toml path to `workers/wrangler.toml`.
205-
- Drop the `docs/oddkit/tools/telemetry_public.md` reference entirely (doc doesn't exist; scope reduces).
206-
- Use observed baseline counts (121 / 31 / 7), not the handoff's stale projections, as the "should decline to zero" target.
207-
- **[C] 2026-04-19T13:58Z (Constraint)** — Budget: one more execution attempt. If the second session halts for a similar reason, escalate to operator — don't keep retrying.
208-
209180
---
210181

211182
## Thesis-validation questions (answered at session end)

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)