diff --git a/promotions/app/models/solidus_promotions/benefit.rb b/promotions/app/models/solidus_promotions/benefit.rb
index cbe7c60509..5128a500ea 100644
--- a/promotions/app/models/solidus_promotions/benefit.rb
+++ b/promotions/app/models/solidus_promotions/benefit.rb
@@ -270,6 +270,12 @@ def available_calculators
     # @param dry_run [Boolean] whether to collect detailed eligibility information
     # @return [Boolean] true when all applicable conditions are eligible
     def eligible_by_applicable_conditions?(promotable, dry_run: false)
+      if dry_run
+        Spree.deprecator.warn <<~MSG
+          Passing `dry_run` to `#eligible_by_applicable_conditions` is deprecated. If you want to check promotion
+          eligibility, use the `SolidusPromotions::PromotionEligibilityChecker` service object instead.
+        MSG
+      end
       conditions.map do |condition|
         next unless condition.applicable?(promotable)
         eligible = condition.eligible?(promotable)
diff --git a/promotions/app/models/solidus_promotions/load_promotions.rb b/promotions/app/models/solidus_promotions/load_promotions.rb
index 58fe641b29..ca385d9c95 100644
--- a/promotions/app/models/solidus_promotions/load_promotions.rb
+++ b/promotions/app/models/solidus_promotions/load_promotions.rb
@@ -3,6 +3,12 @@
 module SolidusPromotions
   class LoadPromotions
     def initialize(order:, dry_run_promotion: nil)
+      if dry_run_promotion
+        Spree.deprecator.warn <<~MSG
+          Passing `dry_run_promotion` to `SolidusPromotions::LoadPromotions` is deprecated.
+          Use `Spree::Config.promotions.eligibility_checker_class.new(order: order, promotion: promotion).call` instead.
+        MSG
+      end
       @order = order
       @dry_run_promotion = dry_run_promotion
     end
diff --git a/promotions/app/models/solidus_promotions/order_adjuster.rb b/promotions/app/models/solidus_promotions/order_adjuster.rb
index 9a1fae8b72..d9b1f53fa3 100644
--- a/promotions/app/models/solidus_promotions/order_adjuster.rb
+++ b/promotions/app/models/solidus_promotions/order_adjuster.rb
@@ -5,6 +5,12 @@ class OrderAdjuster
     attr_reader :order, :promotions, :dry_run
 
     def initialize(order, dry_run_promotion: nil)
+      if dry_run_promotion
+        Spree.deprecator.warn <<~MSG
+          Passing `dry_run_promotion` to `SolidusPromotions::OrderAdjuster` is deprecated.
+          Use `Spree::Config.promotions.eligibility_checker_class.new(order: order, promotion: promotion).call` instead.
+        MSG
+      end
       @order = order
       @dry_run = !!dry_run_promotion
       @promotions = SolidusPromotions::LoadPromotions.new(
diff --git a/promotions/app/models/solidus_promotions/order_adjuster/discount_order.rb b/promotions/app/models/solidus_promotions/order_adjuster/discount_order.rb
index 441c80df1e..5cc1006bb9 100644
--- a/promotions/app/models/solidus_promotions/order_adjuster/discount_order.rb
+++ b/promotions/app/models/solidus_promotions/order_adjuster/discount_order.rb
@@ -6,6 +6,12 @@ class DiscountOrder
       attr_reader :order, :promotions, :dry_run
 
       def initialize(order, promotions, dry_run: false)
+        if dry_run
+          Spree.deprecator.warn <<~MSG
+            Passing `dry_run` to `SolidusPromotions::OrderAdjuster::DiscountOrder` is deprecated.
+            Use `Spree::Config.promotions.eligibility_checker_class.new(order: order, promotion: promotion).call` instead.
+          MSG
+        end
         @order = order
         @promotions = promotions
         @dry_run = dry_run
@@ -46,27 +52,20 @@ def perform_order_benefits(lane_benefits, lane)
       def adjust_line_items(benefits)
         order.discountable_line_items.filter_map do |line_item|
           next unless line_item.variant.product.promotionable?
-
-          discounts = generate_discounts(benefits, line_item)
-          chosen_discounts = SolidusPromotions.config.discount_chooser_class.new(discounts).call
-          (line_item.current_lane_discounts - chosen_discounts).each(&:mark_for_destruction)
+          generate_discounts(benefits, line_item)
         end
       end
 
       def adjust_shipments(benefits)
         order.shipments.map do |shipment|
-          discounts = generate_discounts(benefits, shipment)
-          chosen_discounts = SolidusPromotions.config.discount_chooser_class.new(discounts).call
-          (shipment.current_lane_discounts - chosen_discounts).each(&:mark_for_destruction)
+          generate_discounts(benefits, shipment)
         end
       end
 
       def adjust_shipping_rates(benefits)
         order.shipments.flat_map(&:shipping_rates).filter_map do |rate|
           next unless rate.cost
-          discounts = generate_discounts(benefits, rate)
-          chosen_discounts = SolidusPromotions.config.discount_chooser_class.new(discounts).call
-          (rate.current_lane_discounts - chosen_discounts).each(&:mark_for_destruction)
+          generate_discounts(benefits, rate)
         end
       end
 
@@ -78,9 +77,11 @@ def eligible_benefits_for_promotable(possible_benefits, promotable)
 
       def generate_discounts(possible_benefits, item)
         eligible_benefits = eligible_benefits_for_promotable(possible_benefits, item)
-        eligible_benefits.filter_map do |benefit|
+        discounts = eligible_benefits.filter_map do |benefit|
           benefit.can_discount?(item) && benefit.discount(item)
         end
+        chosen_discounts = SolidusPromotions.config.discount_chooser_class.new(discounts).call
+        (item.current_lane_discounts - chosen_discounts).each(&:mark_for_destruction)
       end
     end
   end
diff --git a/promotions/app/models/solidus_promotions/promotion.rb b/promotions/app/models/solidus_promotions/promotion.rb
index 36a019b4ab..a80bf66333 100644
--- a/promotions/app/models/solidus_promotions/promotion.rb
+++ b/promotions/app/models/solidus_promotions/promotion.rb
@@ -152,6 +152,7 @@ def products
     def eligibility_results
       @eligibility_results ||= SolidusPromotions::EligibilityResults.new(self)
     end
+    deprecate eligibility_results: "Please use the `SolidusPromotions::PromotionEligibilityChecker` service object instead", deprecator: Spree.deprecator
 
     private
 
diff --git a/promotions/app/models/solidus_promotions/promotion_eligibility_checker.rb b/promotions/app/models/solidus_promotions/promotion_eligibility_checker.rb
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000..750a08ea09
--- /dev/null
+++ b/promotions/app/models/solidus_promotions/promotion_eligibility_checker.rb
@@ -0,0 +1,60 @@
+# frozen_string_literal: true
+
+module SolidusPromotions
+  class PromotionEligibilityChecker
+    attr_reader :results
+
+    def initialize(order:, promotion:)
+      @order = order
+      @promotion = promotion
+      @results = SolidusPromotions::EligibilityResults.new(promotion)
+    end
+
+    def call
+      SolidusPromotions::PromotionLane.set(current_lane: promotion.lane) do
+        promotion.benefits.any? do |benefit|
+          # We're running this first and storing the result so the following
+          # block does not short-circuit on ineligible items, and we get all errors.
+          order_eligible = applicable_conditions_eligible?(order, benefit)
+          (
+            order.line_items.any? do |line_item|
+              check_item(line_item, benefit)
+            end || order.shipments.any? do |shipment|
+              check_item(shipment, benefit)
+            end
+          ) && order_eligible
+        end
+      end
+    end
+
+    private
+
+    attr_reader :order, :promotion
+
+    def check_item(item, benefit)
+      benefit.can_discount?(item) &&
+        applicable_conditions_eligible?(item, benefit)
+    end
+
+    def applicable_conditions_eligible?(item, benefit)
+      benefit.conditions.map do |condition|
+        next unless condition.applicable?(item)
+        eligible = !!condition.eligible?(item)
+
+        if condition.eligibility_errors.details[:base].first
+          code = condition.eligibility_errors.details[:base].first[:error_code]
+          message = condition.eligibility_errors.full_messages.first
+        end
+        results.add(
+          item: item,
+          condition: condition,
+          success: eligible,
+          code: eligible ? nil : (code || :coupon_code_unknown_error),
+          message: eligible ? nil : (message || I18n.t(:coupon_code_unknown_error, scope: [:solidus_promotions, :eligibility_errors]))
+        )
+
+        eligible
+      end.compact.all?
+    end
+  end
+end
diff --git a/promotions/app/models/solidus_promotions/promotion_handler/coupon.rb b/promotions/app/models/solidus_promotions/promotion_handler/coupon.rb
index 098b6ae1b9..7c4f60c874 100644
--- a/promotions/app/models/solidus_promotions/promotion_handler/coupon.rb
+++ b/promotions/app/models/solidus_promotions/promotion_handler/coupon.rb
@@ -77,10 +77,10 @@ def handle_present_promotion
         return promotion_usage_limit_exceeded if promotion.usage_limit_exceeded? || promotion_code.usage_limit_exceeded?
         return promotion_applied if promotion_exists_on_order?(order, promotion)
 
-        # Try applying this promotion, with no effects
-        Spree::Config.promotions.order_adjuster_class.new(order, dry_run_promotion: promotion).call
+        # Check promotion eligibility
+        checker = Spree::Config.promotions.eligibility_checker_class.new(order: order, promotion: promotion)
 
-        if promotion.eligibility_results.success?
+        if checker.call
           order.solidus_order_promotions.create!(
             promotion: promotion,
             promotion_code: promotion_code
@@ -88,13 +88,13 @@ def handle_present_promotion
           order.recalculate
           set_success_code :coupon_code_applied
         else
-          set_promotion_eligibility_error(promotion)
+          set_promotion_eligibility_error(checker.results)
         end
       end
 
-      def set_promotion_eligibility_error(promotion)
-        eligibility_error = promotion.eligibility_results.detect { |result| !result.success }
-        set_error_code(eligibility_error.code, error: eligibility_error.message, errors: promotion.eligibility_results.error_messages)
+      def set_promotion_eligibility_error(results)
+        eligibility_error = results.detect { |result| !result.success }
+        set_error_code(eligibility_error.code, error: eligibility_error.message, errors: results.error_messages)
       end
 
       def promotion_usage_limit_exceeded
diff --git a/promotions/app/models/solidus_promotions/promotion_handler/page.rb b/promotions/app/models/solidus_promotions/promotion_handler/page.rb
index 1855aa4988..80a1ff4f38 100644
--- a/promotions/app/models/solidus_promotions/promotion_handler/page.rb
+++ b/promotions/app/models/solidus_promotions/promotion_handler/page.rb
@@ -3,20 +3,20 @@
 module SolidusPromotions
   module PromotionHandler
     class Page
-      attr_reader :order, :path
+      attr_reader :order, :path, :checker
 
       def initialize(order, path)
         @order = order
         @path = path.delete_prefix("/")
+        @checker = Spree::Config.promotions.eligibility_checker_class.new(order: order, promotion: promotion)
       end
 
+      delegate :results, to: :checker
+
       def activate
-        if promotion
-          Spree::Config.promotions.order_adjuster_class.new(order, dry_run_promotion: promotion).call
-          if promotion.eligibility_results.success?
-            order.solidus_promotions << promotion
-            order.recalculate
-          end
+        if promotion && checker.call
+          order.solidus_promotions << promotion
+          order.recalculate
         end
       end
 
diff --git a/promotions/lib/solidus_promotions/configuration.rb b/promotions/lib/solidus_promotions/configuration.rb
index 06a0773065..ae36f82d1c 100644
--- a/promotions/lib/solidus_promotions/configuration.rb
+++ b/promotions/lib/solidus_promotions/configuration.rb
@@ -8,6 +8,11 @@ class Configuration < Spree::Preferences::Configuration
 
     class_name_attribute :order_adjuster_class, default: "SolidusPromotions::OrderAdjuster"
 
+    # Service object that checks whether a promotion is eligible for an order.
+    # @!attribute [rw] eligibility_checker_class
+    #   @return [String] Defaults to "SolidusPromotions::PromotionEligibilityChecker".
+    class_name_attribute :eligibility_checker_class, default: "SolidusPromotions::PromotionEligibilityChecker"
+
     class_name_attribute :coupon_code_handler_class, default: "SolidusPromotions::PromotionHandler::Coupon"
 
     # The class used to normalize coupon codes before saving or lookup.
diff --git a/promotions/spec/lib/solidus_promotions/configuration_spec.rb b/promotions/spec/lib/solidus_promotions/configuration_spec.rb
index 7e10c306f2..cf7826c3d3 100644
--- a/promotions/spec/lib/solidus_promotions/configuration_spec.rb
+++ b/promotions/spec/lib/solidus_promotions/configuration_spec.rb
@@ -19,6 +19,12 @@
     end
   end
 
+  describe ".eligibility_checker_class" do
+    it "is the standard eligibility checker" do
+      expect(subject.eligibility_checker_class).to eq(SolidusPromotions::PromotionEligibilityChecker)
+    end
+  end
+
   describe ".advertiser_class" do
     it "is the standard advertiser" do
       expect(subject.advertiser_class).to eq(SolidusPromotions::PromotionAdvertiser)
diff --git a/promotions/spec/models/solidus_promotions/benefit_spec.rb b/promotions/spec/models/solidus_promotions/benefit_spec.rb
index 96a0b09027..ededd39a4c 100644
--- a/promotions/spec/models/solidus_promotions/benefit_spec.rb
+++ b/promotions/spec/models/solidus_promotions/benefit_spec.rb
@@ -353,7 +353,7 @@ def line_item_eligible?(_)
 
         it { is_expected.to be true }
 
-        context "with dry_run true" do
+        context "with dry_run true", :silence_deprecations do
           let(:dry_run) { true }
 
           it { is_expected.to be true }
@@ -373,7 +373,7 @@ def line_item_eligible?(_)
       let(:promotable) { order.line_items.first }
       it { is_expected.to be true }
 
-      context "with dry_run true" do
+      context "with dry_run true", :silence_deprecations do
         let(:dry_run) { true }
 
         it { is_expected.to be true }
@@ -391,7 +391,7 @@ def line_item_eligible?(_)
 
         it { is_expected.to be false }
 
-        context "with dry_run true" do
+        context "with dry_run true", :silence_deprecations do
           let(:dry_run) { true }
 
           it { is_expected.to be false }
@@ -425,14 +425,14 @@ def order_eligible?(_)
 
         it { is_expected.to be false }
 
-        it "only asks the first condition and does not collect eligibility errors" do
+        it "only asks the first condition and does not collect eligibility errors", :silence_deprecations do
           expect(taxon_condition).to receive(:order_eligible?).and_call_original
           expect(product_condition).not_to receive(:order_eligible?)
           subject
           expect(promotion.eligibility_results.error_messages).to be_empty
         end
 
-        context "if dry_run is true" do
+        context "if dry_run is true", :silence_deprecations do
           let(:dry_run) { true }
           it { is_expected.to be false }
 
diff --git a/promotions/spec/models/solidus_promotions/order_adjuster/discount_order_spec.rb b/promotions/spec/models/solidus_promotions/order_adjuster/discount_order_spec.rb
index 611b34debb..e1820fcd24 100644
--- a/promotions/spec/models/solidus_promotions/order_adjuster/discount_order_spec.rb
+++ b/promotions/spec/models/solidus_promotions/order_adjuster/discount_order_spec.rb
@@ -32,178 +32,4 @@
       expect { subject }.not_to raise_exception
     end
   end
-
-  describe "collecting eligibility results in a dry run" do
-    let(:shirt) { create(:product, name: "Shirt") }
-    let(:order) { create(:order_with_line_items, line_items_attributes: [{variant: shirt.master, quantity: 1}]) }
-    let(:conditions) { [product_condition] }
-    let!(:promotion) { create(:solidus_promotion, :with_adjustable_benefit, conditions: conditions, name: "20% off Shirts", apply_automatically: true) }
-    let(:product_condition) { SolidusPromotions::Conditions::OrderProduct.new(products: [shirt]) }
-    let(:promotions) { [promotion] }
-    let(:discounter) { described_class.new(order, promotions, dry_run: true) }
-
-    subject { discounter.call }
-
-    it "will collect eligibility results" do
-      subject
-
-      expect(promotion.eligibility_results.first.success).to be true
-      expect(promotion.eligibility_results.first.code).to be nil
-      expect(promotion.eligibility_results.first.condition).to eq(product_condition)
-      expect(promotion.eligibility_results.first.message).to be nil
-      expect(promotion.eligibility_results.first.item).to eq(order)
-    end
-
-    it "can tell us about success" do
-      subject
-      expect(promotion.eligibility_results.success?).to be true
-    end
-
-    context "with two conditions" do
-      let(:conditions) { [product_condition, item_total_condition] }
-      let(:item_total_condition) { SolidusPromotions::Conditions::ItemTotal.new(preferred_amount: 2000) }
-
-      it "will collect eligibility results" do
-        subject
-
-        expect(promotion.eligibility_results.first.success).to be true
-        expect(promotion.eligibility_results.first.code).to be nil
-        expect(promotion.eligibility_results.first.condition).to eq(product_condition)
-        expect(promotion.eligibility_results.first.message).to be nil
-        expect(promotion.eligibility_results.first.item).to eq(order)
-        expect(promotion.eligibility_results.last.success).to be false
-        expect(promotion.eligibility_results.last.condition).to eq(item_total_condition)
-        expect(promotion.eligibility_results.last.code).to eq :item_total_less_than_or_equal
-        expect(promotion.eligibility_results.last.message).to eq "This coupon code can't be applied to orders less than or equal to $2,000.00."
-        expect(promotion.eligibility_results.last.item).to eq(order)
-      end
-
-      it "can tell us about success" do
-        subject
-        expect(promotion.eligibility_results.success?).to be false
-      end
-
-      it "has errors for this promo" do
-        subject
-        expect(promotion.eligibility_results.error_messages).to eq([
-          "This coupon code can't be applied to orders less than or equal to $2,000.00."
-        ])
-      end
-    end
-
-    context "with an order with multiple line items and an item-level condition" do
-      let(:pants) { create(:product, name: "Pants") }
-      let(:order) do
-        create(
-          :order_with_line_items,
-          line_items_attributes: [{variant: shirt.master, quantity: 1}, {variant: pants.master, quantity: 1}]
-        )
-      end
-
-      let(:shirt_product_condition) { SolidusPromotions::Conditions::LineItemProduct.new(products: [shirt]) }
-      let(:conditions) { [shirt_product_condition] }
-
-      it "can tell us about success" do
-        subject
-        # This is successful, because one of the line item conditions matches
-        expect(promotion.eligibility_results.success?).to be true
-      end
-
-      it "has no errors for this promo" do
-        subject
-        expect(promotion.eligibility_results.error_messages).to be_empty
-      end
-
-      context "with a second line item level condition" do
-        let(:hats) { create(:taxon, name: "Hats", products: [hat]) }
-        let(:hat) { create(:product) }
-        let(:hat_product_condition) { SolidusPromotions::Conditions::LineItemTaxon.new(taxons: [hats]) }
-        let(:conditions) { [shirt_product_condition, hat_product_condition] }
-
-        it "can tell us about success" do
-          subject
-          expect(promotion.eligibility_results.success?).to be false
-        end
-
-        it "has errors for this promo" do
-          subject
-          expect(promotion.eligibility_results.error_messages).to eq([
-            "This coupon code could not be applied to the cart at this time."
-          ])
-        end
-      end
-    end
-
-    context "when the order must not contain a shirt" do
-      let(:no_shirt_condition) { SolidusPromotions::Conditions::OrderProduct.new(products: [shirt], preferred_match_policy: "none") }
-      let(:conditions) { [no_shirt_condition] }
-
-      it "can tell us about success" do
-        subject
-        # This is successful, because the order has a shirt
-        expect(promotion.eligibility_results.success?).to be false
-      end
-    end
-
-    context "where one benefit succeeds and another errors" do
-      let(:usps) { create(:shipping_method) }
-      let(:ups_ground) { create(:shipping_method) }
-      let(:order) { create(:order_with_line_items, line_items_attributes: [{variant: shirt.master, quantity: 1}], shipping_method: ups_ground) }
-      let(:product_condition) { SolidusPromotions::Conditions::OrderProduct.new(products: [shirt]) }
-      let(:shipping_method_condition) { SolidusPromotions::Conditions::ShippingMethod.new(preferred_shipping_method_ids: [usps.id]) }
-      let(:ten_off_items) { SolidusPromotions::Calculators::Percent.create!(preferred_percent: 10) }
-      let(:ten_off_shipping) { SolidusPromotions::Calculators::Percent.create!(preferred_percent: 10) }
-      let(:shipping_benefit) { SolidusPromotions::Benefits::AdjustShipment.new(calculator: ten_off_shipping) }
-      let(:line_item_benefit) { SolidusPromotions::Benefits::AdjustLineItem.new(calculator: ten_off_items) }
-      let(:benefits) { [shipping_benefit, line_item_benefit] }
-      let(:conditions) { [product_condition, shipping_method_condition] }
-      let!(:promotion) { create(:solidus_promotion, benefits: benefits, name: "10% off Shirts and USPS Shipping", apply_automatically: true) }
-
-      before do
-        shipping_benefit.conditions << shipping_method_condition
-        line_item_benefit.conditions << product_condition
-      end
-
-      it "can tell us about success" do
-        subject
-        expect(promotion.eligibility_results.success?).to be true
-      end
-
-      it "can tell us about errors" do
-        subject
-        expect(promotion.eligibility_results.error_messages).to eq(["This coupon code could not be applied to the cart at this time."])
-      end
-    end
-
-    context "with no conditions" do
-      let(:conditions) { [] }
-
-      it "has no errors for this promo" do
-        subject
-        expect(promotion.eligibility_results.error_messages).to be_empty
-      end
-    end
-
-    context "with an ineligible order-level condition" do
-      let(:mug) { create(:product) }
-      let(:order_condition) { SolidusPromotions::Conditions::NthOrder.new(preferred_nth_order: 2) }
-      let(:line_item_condition) { SolidusPromotions::Conditions::LineItemProduct.new(products: [mug]) }
-      let(:conditions) { [order_condition, line_item_condition] }
-
-      it "can tell us about success" do
-        subject
-        expect(promotion.eligibility_results.success?).to be false
-      end
-
-      it "can tell us about all the errors", :pending do
-        subject
-        expect(promotion.eligibility_results.error_messages).to eq(
-          [
-            "This coupon code could not be applied to the cart at this time.",
-            "You need to add an applicable product before applying this coupon code."
-          ]
-        )
-      end
-    end
-  end
 end
diff --git a/promotions/spec/models/solidus_promotions/order_adjuster_spec.rb b/promotions/spec/models/solidus_promotions/order_adjuster_spec.rb
index 7e44093367..8429aec10f 100644
--- a/promotions/spec/models/solidus_promotions/order_adjuster_spec.rb
+++ b/promotions/spec/models/solidus_promotions/order_adjuster_spec.rb
@@ -39,7 +39,7 @@
       end
     end
 
-    context "when on a dry run" do
+    context "when on a dry run", :silence_deprecations do
       let(:dry_run_promotion) { promotion }
 
       subject do
diff --git a/promotions/spec/models/solidus_promotions/promotion_eligibility_checker_spec.rb b/promotions/spec/models/solidus_promotions/promotion_eligibility_checker_spec.rb
new file mode 100644
index 0000000000..3bd1ecb6c9
--- /dev/null
+++ b/promotions/spec/models/solidus_promotions/promotion_eligibility_checker_spec.rb
@@ -0,0 +1,194 @@
+# frozen_string_literal: true
+
+require "rails_helper"
+
+RSpec.describe SolidusPromotions::PromotionEligibilityChecker do
+  describe "collecting eligibility results in a dry run" do
+    let(:shirt) { create(:product, name: "Shirt") }
+    let(:order) { create(:order_with_line_items, line_items_attributes: [{variant: shirt.master, quantity: 1}]) }
+    let(:conditions) { [product_condition] }
+    let!(:promotion) { create(:solidus_promotion, :with_adjustable_benefit, conditions: conditions, name: "20% off Shirts", apply_automatically: true) }
+    let(:product_condition) { SolidusPromotions::Conditions::OrderProduct.new(products: [shirt]) }
+    let(:checker) { described_class.new(order:, promotion:) }
+
+    subject { checker.call }
+
+    it { is_expected.to be true }
+
+    it "will collect eligibility results" do
+      subject
+
+      expect(checker.results.first.success).to be true
+      expect(checker.results.first.code).to be nil
+      expect(checker.results.first.condition).to eq(product_condition)
+      expect(checker.results.first.message).to be nil
+      expect(checker.results.first.item).to eq(order)
+    end
+
+    it "can tell us about success" do
+      subject
+      expect(checker.results.success?).to be true
+    end
+
+    context "with two conditions" do
+      let(:conditions) { [product_condition, item_total_condition] }
+      let(:item_total_condition) { SolidusPromotions::Conditions::ItemTotal.new(preferred_amount: 2000) }
+
+      it { is_expected.to be false }
+
+      it "will collect eligibility results" do
+        subject
+
+        expect(checker.results.first.success).to be true
+        expect(checker.results.first.code).to be nil
+        expect(checker.results.first.condition).to eq(product_condition)
+        expect(checker.results.first.message).to be nil
+        expect(checker.results.first.item).to eq(order)
+        expect(checker.results.last.success).to be false
+        expect(checker.results.last.condition).to eq(item_total_condition)
+        expect(checker.results.last.code).to eq :item_total_less_than_or_equal
+        expect(checker.results.last.message).to eq "This coupon code can't be applied to orders less than or equal to $2,000.00."
+        expect(checker.results.last.item).to eq(order)
+      end
+
+      it "can tell us about success" do
+        subject
+        expect(checker.results.success?).to be false
+      end
+
+      it "has errors for this promo" do
+        subject
+        expect(checker.results.error_messages).to eq([
+          "This coupon code can't be applied to orders less than or equal to $2,000.00."
+        ])
+      end
+    end
+
+    context "with an order with multiple line items and an item-level condition" do
+      let(:pants) { create(:product, name: "Pants") }
+      let(:order) do
+        create(
+          :order_with_line_items,
+          line_items_attributes: [{variant: shirt.master, quantity: 1}, {variant: pants.master, quantity: 1}]
+        )
+      end
+
+      let(:shirt_product_condition) { SolidusPromotions::Conditions::LineItemProduct.new(products: [shirt]) }
+      let(:conditions) { [shirt_product_condition] }
+
+      # This is successful, because one of the line item conditions matches
+      it { is_expected.to be true }
+
+      it "can tell us about success" do
+        subject
+        expect(checker.results.success?).to be true
+      end
+
+      it "has no errors for this promo" do
+        subject
+        expect(checker.results.error_messages).to be_empty
+      end
+
+      context "with a second line item level condition" do
+        let(:hats) { create(:taxon, name: "Hats", products: [hat]) }
+        let(:hat) { create(:product) }
+        let(:hat_product_condition) { SolidusPromotions::Conditions::LineItemTaxon.new(taxons: [hats]) }
+        let(:conditions) { [shirt_product_condition, hat_product_condition] }
+
+        it { is_expected.to be false }
+
+        it "can tell us about success" do
+          subject
+          expect(checker.results.success?).to be false
+        end
+
+        it "has errors for this promo" do
+          subject
+          expect(checker.results.error_messages).to eq([
+            "This coupon code could not be applied to the cart at this time."
+          ])
+        end
+      end
+    end
+
+    context "when the order must not contain a shirt" do
+      let(:no_shirt_condition) { SolidusPromotions::Conditions::OrderProduct.new(products: [shirt], preferred_match_policy: "none") }
+      let(:conditions) { [no_shirt_condition] }
+
+      # This is unsuccessful, because the order has a shirt
+      it { is_expected.to be false }
+
+      it "can tell us about success" do
+        subject
+        expect(checker.results.success?).to be false
+      end
+    end
+
+    context "where one benefit succeeds and another errors" do
+      let(:usps) { create(:shipping_method) }
+      let(:ups_ground) { create(:shipping_method) }
+      let(:order) { create(:order_with_line_items, line_items_attributes: [{variant: shirt.master, quantity: 1}], shipping_method: ups_ground) }
+      let(:product_condition) { SolidusPromotions::Conditions::OrderProduct.new(products: [shirt]) }
+      let(:shipping_method_condition) { SolidusPromotions::Conditions::ShippingMethod.new(preferred_shipping_method_ids: [usps.id]) }
+      let(:ten_off_items) { SolidusPromotions::Calculators::Percent.create!(preferred_percent: 10) }
+      let(:ten_off_shipping) { SolidusPromotions::Calculators::Percent.create!(preferred_percent: 10) }
+      let(:shipping_benefit) { SolidusPromotions::Benefits::AdjustShipment.new(calculator: ten_off_shipping) }
+      let(:line_item_benefit) { SolidusPromotions::Benefits::AdjustLineItem.new(calculator: ten_off_items) }
+      let(:benefits) { [shipping_benefit, line_item_benefit] }
+      let(:conditions) { [product_condition, shipping_method_condition] }
+      let!(:promotion) { create(:solidus_promotion, benefits: benefits, name: "10% off Shirts and USPS Shipping", apply_automatically: true) }
+
+      before do
+        shipping_benefit.conditions << shipping_method_condition
+        line_item_benefit.conditions << product_condition
+      end
+
+      it { is_expected.to be true }
+
+      it "can tell us about success" do
+        subject
+        expect(checker.results.success?).to be true
+      end
+
+      it "can tell us about errors" do
+        subject
+        expect(checker.results.error_messages).to eq(["This coupon code could not be applied to the cart at this time."])
+      end
+    end
+
+    context "with no conditions" do
+      let(:conditions) { [] }
+
+      it { is_expected.to be true }
+
+      it "has no errors for this promo" do
+        subject
+        expect(checker.results.error_messages).to be_empty
+      end
+    end
+
+    context "with an ineligible order-level condition" do
+      let(:mug) { create(:product) }
+      let(:order_condition) { SolidusPromotions::Conditions::NthOrder.new(preferred_nth_order: 2) }
+      let(:line_item_condition) { SolidusPromotions::Conditions::LineItemProduct.new(products: [mug]) }
+      let(:conditions) { [order_condition, line_item_condition] }
+
+      it { is_expected.to be false }
+
+      it "can tell us about success" do
+        subject
+        expect(checker.results.success?).to be false
+      end
+
+      it "can tell us about all the errors" do
+        subject
+        expect(checker.results.error_messages).to eq(
+          [
+            "This coupon code could not be applied to the cart at this time.",
+            "You need to add an applicable product before applying this coupon code."
+          ]
+        )
+      end
+    end
+  end
+end
diff --git a/promotions/spec/models/solidus_promotions/promotion_handler/coupon_spec.rb b/promotions/spec/models/solidus_promotions/promotion_handler/coupon_spec.rb
index 647efb74b3..1927c8876c 100644
--- a/promotions/spec/models/solidus_promotions/promotion_handler/coupon_spec.rb
+++ b/promotions/spec/models/solidus_promotions/promotion_handler/coupon_spec.rb
@@ -308,7 +308,7 @@ def self.call(value)
     context "with a whole-order adjustment benefit" do
       let!(:benefit) { SolidusPromotions::Benefits::AdjustLineItem.create(promotion: promotion, calculator: calculator) }
       context "right coupon given" do
-        let(:order) { create(:order) }
+        let(:order) { create(:order_with_line_items) }
         let(:calculator) { SolidusPromotions::Calculators::DistributedAmount.new(preferred_amount: 10) }
 
         before do