diff --git a/compile.c b/compile.c
index 6f2b812a1e49ba..1decebe3726155 100644
--- a/compile.c
+++ b/compile.c
@@ -13069,7 +13069,8 @@ inlineable_call(CALL_DATA cd, rb_vm_insns_translator_t * translator)
 
         // A leaf method is a method with the builtin inline flag set
         // or a method that doesn't contain a method call
-        bool is_leaf_method = callee_iseq->body->builtin_inline_p || !contain_method_call;
+        // or a method that was previously inlined
+        bool is_leaf_method = callee_iseq->body->builtin_inline_p || !contain_method_call || callee_iseq->body->param.flags.inlined_iseq;
 
         // Only inline simple and leaf methods
         if (flags & VM_CALL_ARGS_SIMPLE && is_leaf_method) {
@@ -13182,8 +13183,14 @@ inline_iseqs(VALUE *code, size_t pos, iseq_value_itr_t * func, void *_ctx, rb_vm
                 char type = opnd_types[i];
                 switch (type) {
                   case TS_CALLDATA:
-                      iseq->body->ci_size++;
-                      ops[i] = (VALUE)(((CALL_DATA)code[pos + i + 1])->ci);
+                        if (insn_id == BIN(jump_if_cache_miss)) {
+                            // Reuse existing cache
+                            ops[i] = (VALUE)(((CALL_DATA)code[pos + i + 1]));
+                        }
+                        else {
+                            iseq->body->ci_size++;
+                            ops[i] = (VALUE)(((CALL_DATA)code[pos + i + 1])->ci);
+                        }
                       break;
                   case TS_OFFSET:
                       {