[NEW] Open uikit contextual bar#451
Conversation
|
as we had a permission system with Apps Engine, should we allow apps to display Contextual Bar and Modal without the initial interaction from users? |
We were not considering making that change, as it is somewhat risky... as in, without this restriction, what will stop apps from spamming modals to users? 🤔 |
The developers themselves and the marketplace publisher review team. What's to stop an app from spamming messages to users? If we use this same logic in other areas then we will continously hinder apps and what they can do. In my opinion |
Having to check for this kind of "bad" behavior in the review process is not scalable. We've decided to follow this practice as it is something Slack also does, and it looked very reasonable. But we can discuss this again, of course.
This argument could go the other way as well. Like, shouldn't we implement some kind of "rate limiter" to say the least so apps would not abuse this power? Might fall in the same discussion mentioned above 🤷 |
|
In all honesty, I think us erroring on the "safe side" is curtailing creativity more than it's preventing people from spamming. Just my two cents :) |
|
Agree with @graywolf336, we can't prevent all the cases of spamming. But imagine, if we're more open to the Apps Engine, we can bring thousands ideas into life 😄 |
d-gubert
changed the title
4 participants
What? ⛵
Why? 🤔
Links 🌎
PS 👀