Skip to content

[Improvement][Python]: Enhance serialization error messages for better developer experience #37209

@Kalpana-chavhan

Description

@Kalpana-chavhan

Description

Apache Beam Python SDK requires user-defined functions to be serializable for distributed execution. Currently, when users pass non-serializable lambdas or closures (e.g., capturing a file handle or a database connection), the resulting error is a low-level PicklingError or AttributeError that does not explain the context.

Proposed Solution

Interpose a more descriptive RuntimeError during the serialization check in PTransformWithSideInputs (and potentially pickler.py).

The improved message should

  • Identify that a serialization failure occurred during pipeline construction.
  • Explain the requirement for 'picklable' functions in distributed processing.
  • Suggest common fixes (e.g., using module-level functions, checking closure captures, or using DoFn.setup()).

Impact:

Developer Experience: Significantly reduces "head-scratching" time for new users.

Stability: No change to execution logic; pure diagnostic improvement.

Compatibility: No impact on existing pipelines.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

No labels
No labels

Type

No type

Projects

No projects

Relationships

None yet

Development

No branches or pull requests

Issue actions