Consider toolbar_mode wrap to be the new default?

[indigoxela]

There are several options and the default is 'floating'.

That's OK, unless one opens a Backdrop (image / link...) dialog, which "slips under" those expanded toolbar groups.

It works, but it looks odd.

'scrolling' seems to be the least intuitive, 'wrap' might be odd with multiple toolbars, but seems the most intuitive - at least to me.

https://www.tiny.cloud/docs/tinymce/latest/toolbar-configuration-options/#toolbar_mode

Note that you can already adapt this setting, either directly in the json file, or via hook_tinymce_options_alter(), but my suspicion is, that most people aren't aware of that.

Question: which setting's best suited as default?

• 'floating'
• 'sliding'
• 'scrolling'
• 'wrap'

[indigoxela]

To directly compare where it's most likely to be relevant: floating requires to click on the three dots to access the buttons, wrap (as the name implies) just wraps the buttons or button groups.

[izmeez]

I agree wrap is easiest for users and sliding isn't bad if it behaves well with other actions such as image dialog.

[indigoxela]

@izmeez many thanks for your feedback.

Right, "sliding" also has some benefit. I does require a click to access the additional buttons, but works better with Backdrop dialogs on top of it (image / link). 🤔

[yorkshire-pudding]

I think either wrap or sliding would be fine

[indigoxela]

Many thanks for your feedback @izmeez and @yorkshire-pudding

Here's now the (minimal) PR: #159

If somebody set the mode before, either in JSON or in an alter hook, this wouldn't override it, it just changes the initial value. I still belief, "wrap" is the easiest for users. And it aligns with what CKE5 in core looks like - which also just wraps.

[yorkshire-pudding]

Works a treat. Thanks @indigoxela

[izmeez]

Great, go for it.