Avoid unnecessary copying with BufferVec::swap#4902
Avoid unnecessary copying with BufferVec::swap#4902james7132 wants to merge 3 commits intobevyengine:mainfrom
Conversation
|
I think my main concern with this would be people expecting the extracted joints to be populated and their system being scheduled for after the vec was swapped and their thing doesn’t work. It’sa bit of a hidden gotcha. Is there some way to document it on the extracted joints type perhaps? |
An alternative would be just to have a clear/append option that utilizes a faster batch memcpy of the entire thing. Or just write directly from the ExtractedJoints instead of copying it into the BufferVec first. It'd be much faster than pushing one by one. With that said, I'm not sure what kind of use case requires reading the extracted joints in prepare that isn't just skinned meshes. |
superdump
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
I think this is fine for now. If someone wants access to the extracted joints after prepare_skinned_meshes has been run we can deal with that later. Otherwise they can schedule their system to run first.
|
Closing in favor of #6833 for the target use case. |
# Objective Following #4402, extract systems run on the render world instead of the main world, and allow retained state operations on it's resources. We're currently extracting to `ExtractedJoints` and then copying it twice during Prepare. Once into `SkinnedMeshJoints` and again into the actual GPU buffer. This makes #4902 obsolete. ## Solution Cut out the middle copy and directly extract joints into `SkinnedMeshJoints` and remove `ExtractedJoints` entirely. This also removes the per-frame allocation that is being made to send `ExtractedJoints` into the render world. ## Performance On my local machine, this halves the time for `prepare_skinned _meshes` on `many_foxes` (195.75us -> 93.93us on average).  --- ## Changelog Added: `BufferVec::truncate` Added: `BufferVec::extend` Changed: `SkinnedMeshJoints::build` now takes a `&mut BufferVec` instead of a `&mut Vec` as a parameter. Removed: `ExtractedJoints`. ## Migration Guide `ExtractedJoints` has been removed. Read the bound bones from `SkinnedMeshJoints` instead.
# Objective Following #4402, extract systems run on the render world instead of the main world, and allow retained state operations on it's resources. We're currently extracting to `ExtractedJoints` and then copying it twice during Prepare. Once into `SkinnedMeshJoints` and again into the actual GPU buffer. This makes #4902 obsolete. ## Solution Cut out the middle copy and directly extract joints into `SkinnedMeshJoints` and remove `ExtractedJoints` entirely. This also removes the per-frame allocation that is being made to send `ExtractedJoints` into the render world. ## Performance On my local machine, this halves the time for `prepare_skinned _meshes` on `many_foxes` (195.75us -> 93.93us on average).  --- ## Changelog Added: `BufferVec::truncate` Added: `BufferVec::extend` Changed: `SkinnedMeshJoints::build` now takes a `&mut BufferVec` instead of a `&mut Vec` as a parameter. Removed: `ExtractedJoints`. ## Migration Guide `ExtractedJoints` has been removed. Read the bound bones from `SkinnedMeshJoints` instead.
# Objective Following #4402, extract systems run on the render world instead of the main world, and allow retained state operations on it's resources. We're currently extracting to `ExtractedJoints` and then copying it twice during Prepare. Once into `SkinnedMeshJoints` and again into the actual GPU buffer. This makes #4902 obsolete. ## Solution Cut out the middle copy and directly extract joints into `SkinnedMeshJoints` and remove `ExtractedJoints` entirely. This also removes the per-frame allocation that is being made to send `ExtractedJoints` into the render world. ## Performance On my local machine, this halves the time for `prepare_skinned _meshes` on `many_foxes` (195.75us -> 93.93us on average).  --- ## Changelog Added: `BufferVec::truncate` Added: `BufferVec::extend` Changed: `SkinnedMeshJoints::build` now takes a `&mut BufferVec` instead of a `&mut Vec` as a parameter. Removed: `ExtractedJoints`. ## Migration Guide `ExtractedJoints` has been removed. Read the bound bones from `SkinnedMeshJoints` instead.
# Objective Following #4402, extract systems run on the render world instead of the main world, and allow retained state operations on it's resources. We're currently extracting to `ExtractedJoints` and then copying it twice during Prepare. Once into `SkinnedMeshJoints` and again into the actual GPU buffer. This makes #4902 obsolete. ## Solution Cut out the middle copy and directly extract joints into `SkinnedMeshJoints` and remove `ExtractedJoints` entirely. This also removes the per-frame allocation that is being made to send `ExtractedJoints` into the render world. ## Performance On my local machine, this halves the time for `prepare_skinned _meshes` on `many_foxes` (195.75us -> 93.93us on average).  --- ## Changelog Added: `BufferVec::truncate` Added: `BufferVec::extend` Changed: `SkinnedMeshJoints::build` now takes a `&mut BufferVec` instead of a `&mut Vec` as a parameter. Removed: `ExtractedJoints`. ## Migration Guide `ExtractedJoints` has been removed. Read the bound bones from `SkinnedMeshJoints` instead.
# Objective Following #4402, extract systems run on the render world instead of the main world, and allow retained state operations on it's resources. We're currently extracting to `ExtractedJoints` and then copying it twice during Prepare. Once into `SkinnedMeshJoints` and again into the actual GPU buffer. This makes #4902 obsolete. ## Solution Cut out the middle copy and directly extract joints into `SkinnedMeshJoints` and remove `ExtractedJoints` entirely. This also removes the per-frame allocation that is being made to send `ExtractedJoints` into the render world. ## Performance On my local machine, this halves the time for `prepare_skinned _meshes` on `many_foxes` (195.75us -> 93.93us on average).  --- ## Changelog Added: `BufferVec::truncate` Added: `BufferVec::extend` Changed: `SkinnedMeshJoints::build` now takes a `&mut BufferVec` instead of a `&mut Vec` as a parameter. Removed: `ExtractedJoints`. ## Migration Guide `ExtractedJoints` has been removed. Read the bound bones from `SkinnedMeshJoints` instead.
# Objective Following bevyengine#4402, extract systems run on the render world instead of the main world, and allow retained state operations on it's resources. We're currently extracting to `ExtractedJoints` and then copying it twice during Prepare. Once into `SkinnedMeshJoints` and again into the actual GPU buffer. This makes bevyengine#4902 obsolete. ## Solution Cut out the middle copy and directly extract joints into `SkinnedMeshJoints` and remove `ExtractedJoints` entirely. This also removes the per-frame allocation that is being made to send `ExtractedJoints` into the render world. ## Performance On my local machine, this halves the time for `prepare_skinned _meshes` on `many_foxes` (195.75us -> 93.93us on average).  --- ## Changelog Added: `BufferVec::truncate` Added: `BufferVec::extend` Changed: `SkinnedMeshJoints::build` now takes a `&mut BufferVec` instead of a `&mut Vec` as a parameter. Removed: `ExtractedJoints`. ## Migration Guide `ExtractedJoints` has been removed. Read the bound bones from `SkinnedMeshJoints` instead.
# Objective Following bevyengine#4402, extract systems run on the render world instead of the main world, and allow retained state operations on it's resources. We're currently extracting to `ExtractedJoints` and then copying it twice during Prepare. Once into `SkinnedMeshJoints` and again into the actual GPU buffer. This makes bevyengine#4902 obsolete. ## Solution Cut out the middle copy and directly extract joints into `SkinnedMeshJoints` and remove `ExtractedJoints` entirely. This also removes the per-frame allocation that is being made to send `ExtractedJoints` into the render world. ## Performance On my local machine, this halves the time for `prepare_skinned _meshes` on `many_foxes` (195.75us -> 93.93us on average).  --- ## Changelog Added: `BufferVec::truncate` Added: `BufferVec::extend` Changed: `SkinnedMeshJoints::build` now takes a `&mut BufferVec` instead of a `&mut Vec` as a parameter. Removed: `ExtractedJoints`. ## Migration Guide `ExtractedJoints` has been removed. Read the bound bones from `SkinnedMeshJoints` instead.
Objective
prepare_skinned_meshesis repeatedly copying values fromExtractedJointswhen both end up identical to each other and cleared every frame.Solution
BufferVec::swapto directly replace the backingVecwith a pre-prepared one. Avoid the copy.Performance
On
many_foxes,this halves the time spent inprepare_skinned_meshes:Almost all of the time spent in the system is now spent writing the buffer out.
Changelog
Added:
BufferVec::swap.