Skip to content

Conversation

@kphoenix137
Copy link
Collaborator

BloodSlayer -> Bloodslayer

@NiteKat
Copy link
Contributor

NiteKat commented Dec 24, 2025

Is this meant to be two words instead of one, kind of how we had Red Vex but BlackJade in 1.09? Should the correction here be to change this to Blood Slayer instead of Bloodslayer? Bloodslayer isn't a word.

@kphoenix137
Copy link
Collaborator Author

Is this meant to be two words instead of one, kind of how we had Red Vex but BlackJade in 1.09? Should the correction here be to change this to Blood Slayer instead of Bloodslayer? Bloodslayer isn't a word.

Stonecleaver, Crackrust, Thundercall, etc.

1 similar comment
@kphoenix137
Copy link
Collaborator Author

Is this meant to be two words instead of one, kind of how we had Red Vex but BlackJade in 1.09? Should the correction here be to change this to Blood Slayer instead of Bloodslayer? Bloodslayer isn't a word.

Stonecleaver, Crackrust, Thundercall, etc.

@NiteKat
Copy link
Contributor

NiteKat commented Dec 25, 2025

Is this meant to be two words instead of one, kind of how we had Red Vex but BlackJade in 1.09? Should the correction here be to change this to Blood Slayer instead of Bloodslayer? Bloodslayer isn't a word.

Stonecleaver, Crackrust, Thundercall, etc.

While good examples to counter Bloodslayer not being a word, it still feels inconsistent with how BlackJade was modified to Black Jade and not Blackjade, no? Though, that was a unique monster name and not an item name, so maybe it doesn't have to be consistent between the two. Just pointing it out as something to think about for whomever reviews the PR I guess.

@kphoenix137
Copy link
Collaborator Author

Is this meant to be two words instead of one, kind of how we had Red Vex but BlackJade in 1.09? Should the correction here be to change this to Blood Slayer instead of Bloodslayer? Bloodslayer isn't a word.

Stonecleaver, Crackrust, Thundercall, etc.

While good examples to counter Bloodslayer not being a word, it still feels inconsistent with how BlackJade was modified to Black Jade and not Blackjade, no? Though, that was a unique monster name and not an item name, so maybe it doesn't have to be consistent between the two. Just pointing it out as something to think about for whomever reviews the PR I guess.

I'm not sure why BlackJade was changed to Black Jade. It makes more sense to keep it as Blackjade because there was no case difference in vanilla and players read it as BLACKJADE. Problems like these are only visible in DevilutionX.

Copy link
Member

@StephenCWills StephenCWills left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

I'm not sure why BlackJade was changed to Black Jade.

It was almost certainly because "Black Jade" is more consistent with "Red Vex" than "Blackjade". On that note, "Bloodslayer" is more consistent with "Hellslayer" than "Blood Slayer".

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants