Conversation
🏗️ Flight — Lead ReviewPR: What I reviewed
✅ What's goodContent quality is high. The new
Count math is correct. 16 → 20: exactly four new rows added ( Navigation placement is right. Test update is consistent. Experimental warning at top of page is appropriate for alpha-stage software. ✓ PAO history entry is well-written — captures the TDD approach, the cross-linking decision rationale, and the Windows EBUSY environment note. Good institutional memory. 🔍 Minor observations (non-blocking)
SummaryThis is a clean, thorough documentation PR. Structure follows existing reference page conventions, examples are practical, and the model resolution context table is the right level of depth for a reference page. No accuracy concerns, no missing pieces. Verdict: APPROVE |
cc93e17 to
2fc0393
Compare
🧪 FIDO — Quality ReviewPR: #73 — Checklist
DetailTest run: All 22 tests passed. A CLI count: Content quality: The new reference page is well-structured — clear syntax table, arguments/options breakdown, examples with expected output, config file schema, model resolution layer table, and a "See also" section. Cross-links to No issues found. Verdict: APPROVE |
2fc0393 to
9b5b00c
Compare
🧪 FIDO — Re-ReviewPR: #73 — Checklist
❌ Blocker:
|
| Location | Current (broken) | Correct |
|---|---|---|
| "What it does" section | /docs/features/model-selection/#5-layer-model-resolution |
/features/model-selection/#5-layer-model-resolution |
| "Clear the default model" example | /docs/features/model-selection/#5-layer-model-resolution |
/features/model-selection/#5-layer-model-resolution |
| "How it fits" section | /docs/features/model-selection/#5-layer-model-resolution |
/features/model-selection/#5-layer-model-resolution |
| See also — Model selection | /docs/features/model-selection/ |
/features/model-selection/ |
| See also — Switching models | /docs/scenarios/switching-models/ |
/scenarios/switching-models/ |
| See also — Configuration reference | /docs/reference/config/#model-configuration |
/reference/config/#model-configuration |
| See also — CLI reference | /docs/reference/cli/ |
/reference/cli/ |
These will 404 in production if the Astro base is /docs/, because the router would resolve them as /docs/docs/....
✅ Everything else looks good
- Build: clean, no errors
- Tests: 22/22 passing
- No
.squad/files in diff — clean boundary - CLI count math correct (16 → 20, four new rows)
- Nav placement and test assertion consistent
cli.mdnew link uses correct format:/reference/config-model/✓
Verdict: NEEDS FIXES
Strip /docs/ from the 7 links in config-model.md listed above, then re-request review.
Co-authored-by: Copilot <223556219+Copilot@users.noreply.github.com>
9b5b00c to
9f57795
Compare
Flight - Re-ReviewChecked the diff after PAO fixes. Here is the status on each of the 3 items: 1. CLI table placement - NOT FIXEDThe config model rows were moved to after squad plugin marketplace and before squad export. But the requirement was to place them near other config commands - and there are no other squad config commands in the table. The rows cannot satisfy that criterion. The rows are still broadly between the copilot block (rows ~13-15) and the nap block (rows ~29-31) in the table. Moving them one slot down (inserting plugin marketplace in front) does not resolve the grouping problem. Suggested fix: Move the four config model rows to sit directly after squad upgrade --migrate-directory and squad link - those are the other configure-Squad commands near the top of the table. Alternatively, move them to just before squad nap as a terminal configuration/maintenance group. 2. Link format - FIXEDThe CLI table now uses /reference/config-model/ (no /docs/ prefix). Correct. 3. Double blank line in config-model.md - FIXEDNo consecutive blank lines found in the current diff. Verdict: NEEDS FIXES Two of three issues resolved. The CLI table placement still needs a proper fix - the config model rows must be near configuration-related commands (upgrade, link), not floating between the plugin and export rows. |
|
Closing: upstream PR now exists on bradygaster/squad. Work continues there. |
Closes #68
Documents the \squad config model\ CLI command for model pinning.
Source: bradygaster#628 by Brady Gaster
Changes
eference/config-model.md\