Skip to content

Conversation

@esquivalient
Copy link
Member

@esquivalient esquivalient commented Apr 25, 2022

There's a description of Org Roam in the files. I'm using it as part of my organization system. It is awesome.

esquivalient and others added 3 commits March 12, 2022 11:44
Why is this change needed?
--------------------------
I want a better way of recording and organizing knowledge. I reviewed
a bunch of tools in this space including, but not limited to,

- roam
- logseq
- notion
- obsidian

I was surprised to find that Emacs provided the best tooling
overall. I had a lot of requirements, but the key ones were

- no writing style requirements - for example, Roam and Logseq require
  everything to be a node in a tree. I just want to start writing
  without any thought to format. Also, a tree is not always the best
  way to represent information.
- stored in plain text - everything I write should be as portable as
  possible
- stored in a place I can control or export - if I decide to switch
  tools or the tool I'm using goes away, that shouldn't make me start over
- navigate by reference or tag - it should be easy to find linked or
  unlinked references to anything I write about, either because I'm
  implicitly mentioned it somewhere, I've explicitly linked it, or
  I've explicitly grouped the ideas together with a tag

How does it address the issue?
------------------------------
Org Roam is the most popular zettelkasten package for Emacs and does
the above once configured correctly. I also added Org Roam UI, a web
interface for navigating your notes, to make it even easier to see
knowledge relations and find notes I'm looking for.

This implementation doesn't address all of my needs, but committing
this is the last thing I need to do to switch laptops so it's
happening anyway. In particular, I haven't

- made sure that everything that's embedded in a note is stored in the
  note repository (e.g. adding an image should put the image in the
  repo)
- actually turned the org roam directory into a repo for maximum
  storage safety
- installed a flashcard solution
- enabled transclusion
- decided on a publishing feature (if I want one)

Still, it should fire up and work just fine for anyone. I'm already
using it fairly extensively. It might even eventually take the place
of my tmp file.

Any links to any relevant tickets, articles or other resources?
---------------------------------------------------------------
Why is this change needed?
--------------------------
It was recommended by several people while I was setting it up, but I
never want it.

How does it address the issue?
------------------------------
I'm deleting it because it's bad to have code you never use.

Any links to any relevant tickets, articles or other resources?
---------------------------------------------------------------
https://3.basecamp.com/3093825/buckets/14355728/todos/4853961505
@mediocretes
Copy link
Contributor

I get these errors on startup:

Error (use-package): Failed to install exec-path-from-shell: Package ‘exec-path-from-shell-’ is unavailable
Error (use-package): exec-path-from-shell/:init: Symbol’s function definition is void: exec-path-from-shell-initialize
Error (use-package): Cannot load exec-path-from-shell
Warning (initialization): An error occurred while loading ‘/Users/nathan/.emacs.d/init.el’:

File is missing: Creating directory, No such file or directory, /Users/nathan/Dropbox/OrgRoam

Unrelated, maybe the tmp.org should be called something other than tmp, if it's intended to be a quick brain dump file? idk, that's less important than the startup issue.

@esquivalient
Copy link
Member Author

I only remember you have a problem here when I have no access to you. It seems like it failed to fetch from MELPA, but it's definitely still in MELPA. Any chance it was an intermittent failure?

Copy link
Contributor

@mediocretes mediocretes left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

I have the same error as before, but this did drive me to update emacs, but I have the same error as before. Let's look at it together sometime.

@mediocretes
Copy link
Contributor

We debugged this in person. Short version, I had a weird/bad symlink in my elpa/gnu/ directory. We deleted it and let emacs start from scratch. Also, I had split my dropbox into two directories, neither named "~/Dropbox", so we added a symlink with that name to make the dropbox parts of Org Roam work.

@esquivalient esquivalient merged commit c8f3277 into master Jul 6, 2022
@esquivalient esquivalient deleted the emacs_org_roam_m1_with_setup branch July 6, 2022 20:42
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants