C++ Cleanup 1/N: Reorganize YGStyle (#39171) #39221
Closed
Conversation
This file contains hidden or bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
Summary: X-link: facebook/yoga#1349 Pull Request resolved: facebook#39171 ## This diff This diff adds a `style` directory for code related to storing and manipulating styles. `YGStyle`, which is not a public API, is renamed to `yoga::Style` and moved into this folder, alongside `CompactValue`. We will eventually add `ValuePool` alongside this for the next generation style representation. ## This stack The organization of the C++ internals of Yoga are in need of attention. 1. Some of the C++ internals are namespaced, but others not. 2. Some of the namespaces include `detail`, but are meant to be used outside of the translation unit (FB Clang Tidy rules warn on any usage of these) 2. Most of the files are in a flat hierarchy, except for event tracing in its own folder 3. Some files and functions begin with YG, others don’t 4. Some functions are uppercase, others are not 5. Almost all of the interesting logic is in Yoga.cpp, and the file is too large to reason about 6. There are multiple grab bag files where folks put random functions they need in (Utils, BitUtils, Yoga-Internal.h) 7. There is no clear indication from file structure or type naming what is private vs not 8. Handles like `YGNodeRef` and `YGConfigRef` can be used to access internals just by importing headers This stack does some much needed spring cleaning: 1. All non-public headers and C++ implementation details are in separate folders from the root level `yoga`. This will give us room to split up logic and add more files without too large a flat hierarchy 3. All private C++ internals are under the `facebook::yoga` namespace. Details namespaces are only ever used within the same header, as they are intended 4. Utils files are split 5. Most C++ internals drop the YG prefix 6. Most C++ internal function names are all lower camel case 7. We start to split up Yoga.cpp 8. Every header beginning with YG or at the top-level directory is public and C only, with the exception of Yoga-Internal.h which has non-public functions for bindings 9. It is not possible to use private APIs without static casting handles to internal classes This will give us more leeway to continue splitting monolithic files, and consistent guidelines for style in new files as well. These changes should not be breaking to any project using only public Yoga headers. This includes every usage of Yoga in fbsource except for RN Fabric which is currently tied to internals. This refactor should make that boundary clearer. Changelog: [Internal] Reviewed By: shwanton Differential Revision: D48847261 fbshipit-source-id: 3fe9ee0d01c94231880667ad7c28bb6ff36d73c8
facebook-github-bot
added
CLA Signed
Contributor
|
This pull request was exported from Phabricator. Differential Revision: D48847261 |
Base commit: 0c292f3 |
|
Contributor
|
This pull request has been merged in 294a50d. |
facebook-github-bot
pushed a commit
to facebook/yoga
that referenced
this pull request
Aug 30, 2023
Summary: X-link: facebook/react-native#39221 Pull Request resolved: #1349 X-link: facebook/react-native#39171 ## This diff This diff adds a `style` directory for code related to storing and manipulating styles. `YGStyle`, which is not a public API, is renamed to `yoga::Style` and moved into this folder, alongside `CompactValue`. We will eventually add `ValuePool` alongside this for the next generation style representation. ## This stack The organization of the C++ internals of Yoga are in need of attention. 1. Some of the C++ internals are namespaced, but others not. 2. Some of the namespaces include `detail`, but are meant to be used outside of the translation unit (FB Clang Tidy rules warn on any usage of these) 2. Most of the files are in a flat hierarchy, except for event tracing in its own folder 3. Some files and functions begin with YG, others don’t 4. Some functions are uppercase, others are not 5. Almost all of the interesting logic is in Yoga.cpp, and the file is too large to reason about 6. There are multiple grab bag files where folks put random functions they need in (Utils, BitUtils, Yoga-Internal.h) 7. There is no clear indication from file structure or type naming what is private vs not 8. Handles like `YGNodeRef` and `YGConfigRef` can be used to access internals just by importing headers This stack does some much needed spring cleaning: 1. All non-public headers and C++ implementation details are in separate folders from the root level `yoga`. This will give us room to split up logic and add more files without too large a flat hierarchy 3. All private C++ internals are under the `facebook::yoga` namespace. Details namespaces are only ever used within the same header, as they are intended 4. Utils files are split 5. Most C++ internals drop the YG prefix 6. Most C++ internal function names are all lower camel case 7. We start to split up Yoga.cpp 8. Every header beginning with YG or at the top-level directory is public and C only, with the exception of Yoga-Internal.h which has non-public functions for bindings 9. It is not possible to use private APIs without static casting handles to internal classes This will give us more leeway to continue splitting monolithic files, and consistent guidelines for style in new files as well. These changes should not be breaking to any project using only public Yoga headers. This includes every usage of Yoga in fbsource except for RN Fabric which is currently tied to internals. This refactor should make that boundary clearer. Changelog: [Internal] Reviewed By: shwanton Differential Revision: D48847261 fbshipit-source-id: 0fc8c6991e19079f3f0d55d368574757e453fe93
facebook-github-bot
pushed a commit
to facebook/litho
that referenced
this pull request
Aug 30, 2023
Summary: X-link: facebook/react-native#39221 X-link: facebook/yoga#1349 X-link: facebook/react-native#39171 ## This diff This diff adds a `style` directory for code related to storing and manipulating styles. `YGStyle`, which is not a public API, is renamed to `yoga::Style` and moved into this folder, alongside `CompactValue`. We will eventually add `ValuePool` alongside this for the next generation style representation. ## This stack The organization of the C++ internals of Yoga are in need of attention. 1. Some of the C++ internals are namespaced, but others not. 2. Some of the namespaces include `detail`, but are meant to be used outside of the translation unit (FB Clang Tidy rules warn on any usage of these) 2. Most of the files are in a flat hierarchy, except for event tracing in its own folder 3. Some files and functions begin with YG, others don’t 4. Some functions are uppercase, others are not 5. Almost all of the interesting logic is in Yoga.cpp, and the file is too large to reason about 6. There are multiple grab bag files where folks put random functions they need in (Utils, BitUtils, Yoga-Internal.h) 7. There is no clear indication from file structure or type naming what is private vs not 8. Handles like `YGNodeRef` and `YGConfigRef` can be used to access internals just by importing headers This stack does some much needed spring cleaning: 1. All non-public headers and C++ implementation details are in separate folders from the root level `yoga`. This will give us room to split up logic and add more files without too large a flat hierarchy 3. All private C++ internals are under the `facebook::yoga` namespace. Details namespaces are only ever used within the same header, as they are intended 4. Utils files are split 5. Most C++ internals drop the YG prefix 6. Most C++ internal function names are all lower camel case 7. We start to split up Yoga.cpp 8. Every header beginning with YG or at the top-level directory is public and C only, with the exception of Yoga-Internal.h which has non-public functions for bindings 9. It is not possible to use private APIs without static casting handles to internal classes This will give us more leeway to continue splitting monolithic files, and consistent guidelines for style in new files as well. These changes should not be breaking to any project using only public Yoga headers. This includes every usage of Yoga in fbsource except for RN Fabric which is currently tied to internals. This refactor should make that boundary clearer. Changelog: [Internal] Reviewed By: shwanton Differential Revision: D48847261 fbshipit-source-id: 0fc8c6991e19079f3f0d55d368574757e453fe93
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
3 participants
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.
This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.
Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.
Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.
Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.
Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.
You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.
Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.
This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.
Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.
Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.
Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.
Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
Summary:
X-link: facebook/yoga#1349
This diff
This diff adds a
styledirectory for code related to storing and manipulating styles.YGStyle, which is not a public API, is renamed toyoga::Styleand moved into this folder, alongsideCompactValue. We will eventually addValuePoolalongside this for the next generation style representation.This stack
The organization of the C++ internals of Yoga are in need of attention.
detail, but are meant to be used outside of the translation unit (FB Clang Tidy rules warn on any usage of these)YGNodeRefandYGConfigRefcan be used to access internals just by importing headersThis stack does some much needed spring cleaning:
yoga. This will give us room to split up logic and add more files without too large a flat hierarchyfacebook::yoganamespace. Details namespaces are only ever used within the same header, as they are intendedThis will give us more leeway to continue splitting monolithic files, and consistent guidelines for style in new files as well.
These changes should not be breaking to any project using only public Yoga headers. This includes every usage of Yoga in fbsource except for RN Fabric which is currently tied to internals. This refactor should make that boundary clearer.
Changelog: [Internal]
Reviewed By: shwanton
Differential Revision: D48847261