Caution

This repository is no longer updated. To study behaviour differences, see platform matrix test in phpstan/phpstan-doctrine which has far bigger dataset.

How different PHP database drivers fetch numbers and booleans

When a native type is used and when string is returned? This repository aims to verify behaviour of PHP connectors to MySQL, PgSQL and SQLite with different configurations and PHP versions.

• Used wrapper: doctrine/dbal
• Tested PHP versions: 7.2 - 8.3.
• Tested drivers: mysqli, pdo_sqlite, pdo_mysql, pdo_pgsql, pgsql (PHP >= 7.4), sqlite3 (PHP >= 7.4)
• Used databases: mysql:8.0, postgres:13, sqlite:3

Results

• Here is a table with results for default settings running on >= PHP 8.1:

Expression	pdo_mysql, mysqli	pdo_sqlite, sqlite3	pdo_pgsql	pgsql
TRUE	int	int	bool	bool
FALSE	int	int	bool	bool
col_bool	int	int	bool	bool
NOT(col_bool)	int	int	bool	bool
1 > 2	int	int	bool	bool
col_float	float	float	string	float
AVG(col_float)	float	float	string	float
SUM(col_float)	float	float	string	float
MIN(col_float)	float	float	string	float
MAX(col_float)	float	float	string	float
col_decimal	string	float	string	string
0.1	string	float	string	string
0.125e0	float	float	string	string
AVG(col_decimal)	string	float	string	string
AVG(col_int)	string	float	string	string
AVG(col_bigint)	string	float	string	string
SUM(col_decimal)	string	float	string	string
MIN(col_decimal)	string	float	string	string
MAX(col_decimal)	string	float	string	string
1	int	int	int	int
2147483648	int	int	int	int
col_int	int	int	int	int
col_bigint	int	int	int	int
SUM(col_int)	string	int	int	int
LENGTH('')	int	int	int	int
COUNT(*)	int	int	int	int
COUNT(1)	int	int	int	int
COUNT(col_int)	int	int	int	int
MIN(col_int)	int	int	int	int
MIN(col_bigint)	int	int	int	int
MAX(col_int)	int	int	int	int
MAX(col_bigint)	int	int	int	int
col_string	string	string	string	string

Important notes:

• Any tested PDO driver can force string for all values by PDO::ATTR_STRINGIFY_FETCHES: true
  • Exception is pdo_pgsql which does not stringify booleans on < PHP 8.1
• pdo_mysql stringifies all values on < PHP 8.1
  • This can be changed by PDO::ATTR_EMULATE_PREPARES: false
• pdo_sqlite stringifies all values on < PHP 8.1
• mysqli stringifies all values by default when non-prepared statements are used
  • this can be changed by MYSQLI_OPT_INT_AND_FLOAT_NATIVE: false (docs)
• Note that you cannot detect ATTR_STRINGIFY_FETCHES on PDO in any way. See bugreport
• MySQL server treats 1.23 literals as DECIMALS, if you need FLOAT, use 1.23E0 instead (docs)
• Stringified float/decimal numbers may include trailing zeros for some drivers, e.g. 0.000000

Full results visible in the test.

Why?

• This knowledge should help me properly implement precise type infering in phpstan/phpstan-doctrine.

Running the tests

• printf "UID=$(id -u)\nGID=$(id -g)" > .env
• docker-compose up -d
• ./test-all-php-versions.sh