asu error whis bmx7

[der-nele]

hello everybody. my issue is.
if i try to use one of the freifunk profile whith bmx7
"profile-freifunk-80211s-sae-bmx7-batadv" or "profile-freifunk-80211s-sae-bmx7-only"
it say "asu.build.PackageSelectionError"
if i uns the profile "profile-freifunk-80211s-sae-batadv-only" works fine!
https://chef.libremesh.org/?version=21.02.2&target=ath79%2Fgeneric&id=tplink_tl-wdr3600-v1
i wont to use bmx7 so there is my problem.

[der-nele]

i think after i had a look it can be the "=" behinde PROFILE_DEPENDS:
whish is i the tow profiles whith are not working
and not in the other

include $(TOPDIR)/rules.mk

PROFILE_DESCRIPTION:=Use 802.11s with SAE for mesh, route with bmx7 and batman-adv
PROFILE_DEPENDS:=+wpad-mesh-wolfssl +wpa-cli +bmx7 +bmx7-iwinfo +bmx7-json +bmx7-sms +bmx7-table +bmx7-tun +bmx7-uci-config +lime-proto-batadv +bmx7-auto-gw-mode +lime-proto-bmx7 +lime-proto-anygw +uhttpd-mod-lua +shared-state +shared-state-dnsmasq_hosts +shared-state-dnsmasq_leases +shared-state-bat_hosts +wifi-unstuck-wa

include ../../profile.mk

[ilario]

I think that the problem arises from an incompatibility of wpad-basic-wolfssl and wpad-mesh-wolfssl (just because their makefile indicates this, I don't think they are actually incompatible...). So that none of those profiles should compile if you add them to the default packages list there. Weird that the batadv-only is already compiledand available there. Try removing wpad-basic-wolfssl from the list and including the profile's content explicitly to see of there are other packages that caise trouble.
@FreifunkUFO can you also have a look?

[der-nele]

if this ist one mistake than ther have to be an other.
i removed this wpad-basic-wolfssl and add profile-freifunk-80211s-sae-bmx7-batadv
but still asu.build.PackageSelectionError.

part from log

.....
Downloading https://feed.libremesh.org/profiles/Packages.sig
Signature check passed.
Collected errors:

• check_data_file_clashes: Package dnsmasq wants to install file /home/debian/asu/worker2/cache/21.02.2/ath79/generic/build_dir/target-mips_24kc_musl/root-ath79/etc/hotplug.d/ntp/25-dnsmasqsec
  But that file is already provided by package * dnsmasq-dhcpv6
  .....
  auch an @dangowrt
  if ther is a conflikt we can change the list that it is working out of the box?
  (=) maybe change this just to try

PROFILE_DEPENDS: (=) -wpad-basic-wolfssl... +wpad-mesh-wolfssl +wpa-cli +bmx7 +bmx7-iwinfo +bmx7-json +bmx7-sms +bmx7-table +bmx7-tun +bmx7-uci-config +lime-proto-batadv +bmx7-auto-gw-mode +lime-proto-bmx7 +lime-proto-anygw +uhttpd-mod-lua +shared-state +shared-state-dnsmasq_hosts +shared-state-dnsmasq_leases +shared-state-bat_hosts +wifi-unstuck-wa

[ilario]

Ok, so try to replace dnsmasq in the default list of packages with dnsmasq-dhcpv6.
@G10h4ck is that dependency still needed when using OpenWrt 21.02?

[der-nele]

yes this works.
so how can the profile or chef can be change that this is working out of the box. can the chef check packets and choose the right packetes? or can the profile be written in a way "always" works?

[ilario]

I don't know.
@aparcar @G10h4ck @FreifunkUFO ?