Tom Slater's peer review: verification and validation

[amyheather]

Peer review from @tbslater

Verification and Validation

• Typo…

• How easy is this to do? And does it depend on the software used? --> Can't comment on ease, but have add suggestion of R software that can do this.

• I guess the issue with this is the comparison model might be wrong! Even so, it would force you to double check your model is the right one! --> Have add this note

Tests

Super clear 😊

• Just spotted a small typo…

Mathematical Proof of Correctness

• Is there a general rule on how much difference you are willing to tolerate (here you have used 15%)?

• Might benefit from a sentence stating that all tests have passed!

Quality Assurance

No comments 😊