"How many bicycles can be parked here?" UI issues

[rowlap]

How to Reproduce
Click on icon for bicycle parking count. If the dialog is already complete (typically with the correct number), the red circle tick submission button doesn't appear until the answer is deleted and re-entered.

If the user instead decides to ignore and click away, there is a "Discard input?" modal popup.

Expected Behavior
Allow submission of autosuggestion value. Do not show discard prompt without user input.

Versions affected

Version 61.2 on Android 16 on Pixel 9.

[mcliquid]

Thanks, I can reproduce that, too.

[westnordost]

Oh, well, this should in theory also charging station capacity, motorcycle capacity and step count quests, only that maybe those are not asked again when the value has already been recorded some years ago.

Probably it makes sense to use the same behavior as before the UI was redone by @Ercalvez and don't show the previous value at all. (Otherwise the question wouldn't be quite fitting, the question would then have to be "Can still this many bicycles be parked here?" and the UI would need to be a Yes/No UI and only switch the the normal input UI when the user presses no. Sounds too much effort.)

[rowlap]

Eh, if it were up to me I'd prefer not to be reprompted for check_date expiry with a blank form, especially if it's not obvious that the data is already there. Perhaps the existing value could just be hinted in the question.

However I appreciate the "is this still" question sequence is a bigger lift.

[matkoniecz]

don't show the previous value at all

I think it is quite useful as it should reduce how often people make mistakes

[westnordost]

it might, but I'd not implement it at this time because it requires to switch the layout and answer options (yes/no -> OK-based), just like the opening hours quest. Currently, that would result in a somewhat awkward interaction between the parts of the UI that is already migrated to Compose UI and those parts that are not migrated yet.