Incorrect additionalTextEdit applied when auto-importing PHP namespaces

[pyr0hu]

• OS and language server
  • macOS 10.15 -
• How you installed LSP (Package Control or from git?)
  • Package Control
• Minimal reproduction steps
  • create a minimal php package with autoloading
  • create a src/First and src/Second folders
  • add an App class with the appropriate namespaces, so we have e.g. Acme\First\App and Acme\Second\App
  • In a different class e.g. Acme/Start try writing App in a function. It will show two App instance, Acme\First\App and Acme\Second\App.
  • Select the second one
  • It will use the first App's additionalTextEdits and adds use Acme\First\App when I clearly selected the second (tried using tab or enter, doesnt matter)
• Log

{'textEdit': {'range': {'end': {'character': 4, 'line': 6}, 'start': {'character': 2, 'line': 6}}, 'newText': 'App'}, 'additionalTextEdits': [{'range': {'end': {'character': 0, 'line': 4}, 'start': {'character': 22, 'line': 2}}, 'newText': '\n\nuse Acme\\Test\\App;\n\n'}], 'kind': 7, 'detail': 'use Acme\\Test\\App', 'sortText': 'App', 'label': 'App', 'data': 1264852955825781},
{'textEdit': {'range': {'end': {'character': 4, 'line': 6}, 'start': {'character': 2, 'line': 6}}, 'newText': 'App'}, 'additionalTextEdits': [{'range': {'end': {'character': 0, 'line': 4}, 'start': {'character': 22, 'line': 2}}, 'newText': '\n\nuse Acme\\Third\\App;\n\n'}], 'kind': 7, 'detail': 'use Acme\\Third\\App', 'sortText': 'App', 'label': 'App', 'data': 4436429581058069}

From the logs, it's clearly seen that the use expression is correct for the different classes. It just that it always uses the first one and there is no way to import the second namespace

[tomv564]

Sorry, but this cannot be fixed with sublime’s completion API - it does not tell us which completion item was chosen/inserted. Our workaround does a lookup by inserted string, but obviously cannot differentiate between your two ‘App’ imports.

Thanks for the detailed report, hope it’s workable for you otherwise!

[predragnikolic]

Can the new Sublime api for autocompleton handle this? If so can we reopen the issue?

[ayoub-benali]

Yes the new API allows to fix this issue. I would re-open as well but label it for ST4

[tomv564]

Good point, I guess you are referring to using a command with the completion item?

I like to keep the issue list as relevant as possible, so I personally don't see the point of opening this issue until manpower shows up to work on ST4000 features.

[ayoub-benali]

yes the completion item. I am willing to work on this topic, can we have a st4000 branch along side master ?

[tomv564]

Yes, feel free to create a PR to the st4000-exploration branch.

[ayoub-benali]

Thanks