Bug In The Code Stack

A new benchmark for measuring LLM's capability to detect bugs in large codebase.

About

• Similar to the Needle In The Haystack benchmark, the Bug In The Haystack benchmark utilizes Python source code (randomly assembled) as the background noise and syntactic bug as the needle.
• This allows measurement of LLM's capability to retrieve code-related information at a very large context window, which is useful for SWE agent and co-pilot applications.

Example

1 | def fahrenheit_to_celsius(fahrenheit):
2 |   return (fahrenheit - 32) * 5.0/9.0
3 |
4 | def is_prime(num:
5 |     if num <= 1:
6 |         return False
7 |     for i in range(2, int(num**0.5) + 1):
8 |         if num % i == 0:
9 |             return False
10|     return True
Answer: 4, missing_parenthesis

Results

• *All models were evaluated on their latest versions.

Average Accuracy for Each Model (Exc. 16k Results)

1. GPT-4o

2. GPT-4o Mini

3. GPT-4-Turbo

4. Claude-3.5 Sonnet

5. Claude-3 Opus

6. Gemini 1.5 Pro

7. Gemini 1.5 Flash

8. GPT-3.5-Turbo

9. Codestral

10. Llama3-70B

11. Command-R+

12. Gemini-1.0-Pro

Notebooks

• notebooks/bug_in_the_code_stack_python_source_code_preprocessing.ipynb contains Colab notebook for data processing.
• notebooks/bug_in_the_code_stack_experiment_openai.ipynb contains Colab notebook for running the experiment on OpenAI models.
• notebooks/bug_in_the_code_stack_experiment_litellm_openai_gpt4_turbo.ipynb contains Colab notebook for running the experiment on GPT-4-Turbo w/t LiteLLM.
• notebooks/bug_in_the_code_stack_experiment_litellm_openai_gpt4o.ipynb contains Colab notebook for running the experiment on GPT-4o w/t LiteLLM.
• notebooks/bug_in_the_code_stack_experiment_litellm_openai_gpt4o_mini.ipynb contains Colab notebook for running the experiment on GPT-4o Mini w/t LiteLLM.
• notebooks/bug_in_the_code_stack_experiment_litellm_openai_gpt35.ipynb contains Colab notebook for running the experiment on GPT-3.5 w/t LiteLLM.
• notebooks/bug_in_the_code_stack_experiment_litellm_anthropic_claude_35_sonnet.ipynb contains Colab notebook for running the experiment on Claude-3.5 Sonnet w/t LiteLLM.
• notebooks/bug_in_the_code_stack_experiment_litellm_anthropic_claude_3_opus.ipynb contains Colab notebook for running the experiment on Claude-3 Opus w/t LiteLLM.
• notebooks/bug_in_the_code_stack_experiment_litellm_cohere_commandr.ipynb contains Colab notebook for running the experiment on Command-R+ w/t LiteLLM.
• notebooks/bug_in_the_code_stack_experiment_litellm_meta_llama3.ipynb contains Colab notebook for running the experiment on Llama3 70B w/t LiteLLM.
• notebooks/bug_in_the_code_stack_experiment_mistral_codestral.ipynb contains Colab notebook for running the experiment on Mistral Codestral w/t LiteLLM
• notebooks/bug_in_the_code_stack_experiment_qwen_codeqwen_local.ipynb contains Colab notebook for running the experiment on CodeQwen1.5 locally. Make sure to run this on Colab with A100 GPU.
• notebooks/bug_in_the_code_stack_experiment_genai_gemini10.py contains Python script for running the experiment on Gemini-1.0-Pro w/t Generative AI package. Make sure to run this locally (doesn't work on Colab).
• notebooks/bics_helper_result_graphs.ipynb contains helper functions to create beautiful graphs.
• notebooks/bics_result_analysis_graphs.ipynb contains code to analyze the properties of codegen-focused models compared to larger, general-purpose models.

Dataset

• datasets/bug_in_the_code_stack_alpaca_dataset.csv is the preprocessed dataset used for the experiment.

Google Drive

• All notebooks and datasets can also be found at Bug In The Code Stack Google Drive. If you don't have access, please request access to techandy42@gmail.com.