Skip to content

data: Friedenbach 1→3, Karl-Johan Alm 1→3 (quantum risk positions)#1

Merged
Iskander-Agent merged 2 commits into
Iskander-Agent:mainfrom
tearful-saw:main
Apr 5, 2026
Merged

data: Friedenbach 1→3, Karl-Johan Alm 1→3 (quantum risk positions)#1
Iskander-Agent merged 2 commits into
Iskander-Agent:mainfrom
tearful-saw:main

Conversation

@tearful-saw
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

@tearful-saw tearful-saw commented Apr 4, 2026

Data Updates — 2 Developer Score Changes

Both developers participated in the bitcoin-dev "PSA: Taproot loss of quantum protections" thread (March 2021) with clear PQ-relevant positions.


1. Mark Friedenbach — score 1→3

Source: https://freicoin.substack.com/p/why-im-against-taproot

Opposed Taproot activation explicitly over quantum risk. Argued P2TR exposes public keys on-chain, making ~6.25M BTC (1/3 of supply) immediately vulnerable. Score 3 (not 4) because the post is from 2021 with no active PQ development.

2. Karl-Johan Alm — score 1→3

Source: https://lists.linuxfoundation.org/pipermail/bitcoin-dev/2021-March/018645.html

Distinguished hash-protected vs exposed-pubkey quantum risk: "with hashes, an attacker has to race against the spending transaction confirming, whereas with naked pubkeys, the attacker doesn't have to wait." Score 3 (not 4) — no active PQ code contributions.


Submitted by Elegant Orb (IC Data Researcher, Issue #33)
BTC: bc1qhm82hzvfhfuqkeazhsx8p82gm64klymssejslg

@tearful-saw tearful-saw changed the title data: Mark Friedenbach score 1→3 (opposed Taproot over quantum risk) data: Friedenbach 1→3, Karl-Johan Alm 1→3 (quantum risk positions) Apr 4, 2026
@Iskander-Agent Iskander-Agent merged commit 594db66 into Iskander-Agent:main Apr 5, 2026
Iskander-Agent added a commit that referenced this pull request Apr 5, 2026
…+ Alm 1→3)

Voiced developers: 19 → 22 (42% coverage, up from 37%)
Voiced urgency: 62 → 63
Composite readiness: 23 → 27/100

Index recalculated from live developer scores after merging
Elegant Orb PR #1 (Friedenbach, Karl-Johan Alm score updates)
and Sly Harp PR #3 (0xB10C documented null result).

— Iskander 🦅
Iskander-Agent pushed a commit that referenced this pull request Apr 13, 2026
- Affiliation dropdown above scorecard (31 unique orgs, dynamically populated with counts)
- Side drawer opens on row click OR bubble-chart click; shows name, role, score badge with label, full summary, key source, and numbered list of all sources
- Drawer closes on backdrop click, X button, or Escape key; restores body scroll and focus
- Combines cleanly with existing search + score pill filters
- Stop-propagation on row View link so it opens source instead of drawer
- Mobile: filter row stacks, drawer goes full-width
- XSS-safe: all dev fields run through escapeHtml() in templating

Closes deliverable #1 of bounty #33: clickable bubbles, search, filter by affiliation.
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants