Skip to content

RFC: hello-world: remove reference to "name not given"#519

Closed
petertseng wants to merge 1 commit intoexercism:masterfrom
petertseng:hello-world
Closed

RFC: hello-world: remove reference to "name not given"#519
petertseng wants to merge 1 commit intoexercism:masterfrom
petertseng:hello-world

Conversation

@petertseng
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member

@petertseng petertseng commented Jan 30, 2017

This implements the second option "change the hello-world README to be
so vague..." of #520.

As stated in #520, the point of hello-world is to give a very easy
exercise. This helps give an intro to how to fetch, how to submit, and
how to run the test suite for a given language. The README included with
hello-world helps out with that.

The clause "If a name is not given" is very difficult for languages that
do not support overloading functions and/or default function parameters.

This is against the vision of a very easy hello-world. The ideal is a
function that returns "Hello, World!" unconditionally.

By not mentioning the "name not given" in the README, every track that
currently has a hello-world exercise can change it or not, as they
please.

This is a very delicate balance to strike. If we make it too vague, that
is also undesirable. See #322. I cannot be sure that I have gotten it
right in this commit.

@petertseng
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member Author

There is too much going on in this PR. I'll extract some of it in an issue, and make it applicable to all tracks, because as it stands everyone can fairly think that I'm imagining this problem and the problem has nothing to do with them, so it is not worth the time to read this PR.

This implements the second option "change the hello-world README to be
so vague..." of #520.

As stated in #520, the point of hello-world is to give a very easy
exercise. This helps give an intro to how to fetch, how to submit, and
how to run the test suite for a given language. The README included with
hello-world helps out with that.

The clause "If a name is not given" is very difficult for languages that
do not support overloading functions and/or default function parameters.

This is against the vision of a very easy hello-world. The ideal is a
function that returns "Hello, World!" unconditionally.

By not mentioning the "name not given" in the README, every track that
currently has a hello-world exercise can change it or not, as they
please.

This is a very delicate balance to strike. If we make it too vague, that
is also undesirable. See #322. I cannot be sure that I have gotten it
right in this commit.
@Insti
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Insti commented Jan 30, 2017

I don't think this is an ideal solution to the main problem with hello world. See #520

@petertseng
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member Author

Let's close to avoid accidental merges while we examine our options in #520.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants